Review of the Week

ThisNovelBrokeMyReadingBrain

by Orla DevaneThe Cartography of Forgetting
Scroll

Orla Devane

Video Essayist · Unreliable Narrator Specialist · 847 reviews published

Orla Devane, literary reviewer and video essayist, mid-gesture while speaking passionately about a book

Controversial Take

"Reliable narrators are a failure of imagination."

"This is the kind of novel that makes you angry at every other novel you've read this year for being too polite about what fiction can do."

5 / 5

Full Review

The Cartography of Forgetting

Miriam Osei-Bonsu · Faber & Faber · 2025

Literary Fiction

The book opens mid-sentence. Not mid-chapter — mid-sentence, as if you've stumbled into someone's private monologue already in progress. It's a deliberate act of aggression toward the reader, and I mean that as the highest compliment. Miriam Osei-Bonsu doesn't want your comfort. She wants your full attention, your willingness to be lost, your tolerance for ambiguity stretched until it becomes a new kind of understanding.

The narrator, Cass, is unreliable in ways that go beyond the usual tricks. She doesn't simply misremember or deceive; she actively dismantles the mechanisms of her own storytelling mid-paragraph, inserting parenthetical corrections that contradict what she just wrote. By page forty, you stop trusting the chronology entirely. By page ninety, you stop trusting the geography. By the end, you're not entirely sure the character you've been following for two hundred and sixty pages is the same person who began the book — and neither, it seems, is she.

This is the kind of novel that makes you angry at every other novel you've read this year for being too polite about what fiction can do.

Published 14 Feb 2026 · 8 min read

Read more in the app →
WINTER READSDEBUT FICTIONPRIZE LONGLISTORLA'S PICKSREADER FAVOURITESWINTER READSDEBUT FICTIONPRIZE LONGLISTORLA'S PICKSREADER FAVOURITES

Falling Stars

Eight titles our reviewers can't stop talking about this month

01

Orbital

Samantha Harvey

Literary Fiction
02

James

Percival Everett

Historical Fiction
03

The God of the Woods

Lauren Fox

Thriller
04

Intermezzo

Sally Rooney

Contemporary
05

Small Things Like These

Claire Keegan

Novella
06

All Fours

Miranda July

Literary Fiction
07

The Women

Kristin Hannah

Historical Fiction
08

Playground

Richard Powers

Climate Fiction

Marcus Obi

Former Bookseller · Debut Fiction Only · Poet · 203 first novels reviewed

"Debut fiction is where literature actually lives — unguarded, written by people who haven't yet learned what they're not supposed to say."

5 / 5

Full Review

Why I Only Review Debuts

Marcus Obi · Folio Essay · February 2026

Essay

I came to debut fiction by accident. I was bookselling in Bristol, 2019, and a sales rep left an uncorrected proof on the counter — no author bio, no cover art, just a title and 240 pages of the most assured voice I'd read in a decade. The author was twenty-three. She'd never published anything. She'd written the whole thing on her phone during night shifts at a distribution warehouse in Swindon.

That book won nothing. It sold quietly to people who pressed it into the hands of strangers. It is, in my considered opinion, the most important British novel of the last ten years, and almost nobody has heard of it.

This is why I only review debuts. The prize machinery is broken. The literary press reviews the same forty names recycled through the same six publishers. Debut fiction is where literature actually lives — unguarded, unpolished in the best sense, written by people who haven't yet learned what they're not supposed to say.

Theodora Bright's first novel, arriving this March, is exactly this. It will not win the Booker. It should.

Published 20 Feb 2026 · 6 min read

Read more in the app →
Marcus Obi, debut fiction reviewer and former bookseller, looking thoughtfully to the side in a bookshop setting

By The Numbers

203 debuts reviewed. 11 later won major prizes.

You've read the voice. Now carry it everywhere.

Read Tonight

Sharp reviews. Heated takes. Curated reading lists. One trusted voice — in your pocket, every evening.

47kActive Readers
2,400+Reviews Published
4.8★App Store Rating

Enter your number and we'll text you a direct download link for the App Store.

One text, no marketing. Unsubscribe anytime.